COVID-19: Dominic Cummings’s proof fact-checked – What he instructed Commons committee on dealing with of coronavirus pandemic


Dominic Cummings, Boris Johnson’s former senior adviser, has been giving proof to MPs concerning the classes realized for the reason that starting of the pandemic.

The top minister’s former aide made some explosive allegations in regards to the govt’s reaction to COVID-19, and maximum significantly, Well being Secretary Matt Hancock’s function in resolution making.

However whilst a few of Mr Cummings’s claims can also be subsidized up with proof, others fall simply wanting the mark.

Listed below are one of the most assertions he remodeled the mammoth seven-hour Commons Science and Era Committee sitting, checked in opposition to what we all know.

Dominic Cummings giving speaking at the Commons Science and Technology Committee
Dominic Cummings confronted wondering from MPs for over seven hours

:: Care properties

Mr Cummings instructed the committee that during March, Mr Hancock categorically promised that people can be examined sooner than being discharged from hospitals again into residential properties.

He added that this didn’t occur and communicate of a “protecting defend” across the care sector used to be “nonsense”.

Mr Cummings instructed MPs: “The federal government rhetoric used to be that we put a defend round care properties… it used to be whole nonsense.

“The other of hanging a defend round them, we despatched other people with COVID again to care properties.”

Matt Hancock’s declare {that a} “protecting ring” used to be put round care properties used to be made in early Might.

However again on 17 March, Sir Simon Stevens, leader govt of the NHS, wrote to different leader executives of NHS trusts calling for the “pressing discharge” of sufferers to extend medical institution capability forward of the predicted top of infections.

Sandra meets her daughter Kayleigh inside for the first time in over a year
The top minister’s former aide stated Matt Hancock promised no affected person can be despatched again to a care house with out being examined first

There used to be no point out of care house citizens being examined for coronavirus on go back from medical institution within the letter, suggesting it used to be no longer professional coverage.

It states: “Neighborhood well being suppliers should take quick complete duty for pressing discharge of all eligible sufferers known by way of acute suppliers on a discharge record.”

:: Checking out

Mr Cummings instructed the committee the swift building of a check, hint and isolate gadget used to be hampered by way of Mr Hancock short of to stay regulate of the method as a way to fulfil his pledge of 100,000 assessments in keeping with day by way of April 2020.

In mid-April, a “Downing Boulevard supply” made a identical level to The Telegraph, mentioning: “Hancock’s 100,000 goal used to be a reaction to complaint within the media, and he made up our minds to crank out assessments regardless.”

They added: “The 100,000 determine used to be Hancock’s concept – however he made that determine up.”

Health Secretary Matt Hancock delivers the Downing St COVID press conference
Dominic Cummings stated the advent of an efficient check and hint gadget used to be hampered by way of Matt Hancock’s fixation at the 100okay assessments an afternoon goal

On 12 March, Public Well being England stopped doing touch tracing as common transmission had crushed capability, however SAGE mins from 15 March recommend this used to be as a way to prioritise tracing instances in healthcare settings.

SAGE assembly mins from 16 April additionally shed light on the “general duty for [the testing] technique lies with the executive clinical officer” and no longer the well being secretary.

:: Boris Johnson’s non-public feedback

Previous on in his proof consultation, Mr Cummings claimed the top minister stated “COVID used to be most effective killing 80-year-olds” remaining 12 months whilst arguing in opposition to difficult restrictions.

When Labour chief Sir Keir Starmer raised the alleged commentary at PMQs these days, Mr Johnson didn’t cope with it, however stated he’s “assured we took selections in the most productive pursuits of the British other people”.

Mr Cummings additionally claimed he heard the top minister make say “let the our bodies pile top”.

Closing month, Mr Johnson firmly denied pronouncing this.

:: No knowledge

The PM’s former senior aide time and again claimed that “there used to be no knowledge” to base COVID resolution making round within the first few months of 2020.

Boris johnson
Boris Johnson denies he stated ‘let the our bodies pile top’

Mr Cummings instructed MPs the knowledge gadget on Monday 16 March used to be “me, wheeling in a whiteboard, and Simon Stevens studying out numbers from the In depth Care Devices (ICUs)”, including that having a look at knowledge “did not truly occur correctly till mid-April”.

He seems to were regarding knowledge concerning the extent of infections in the United Kingdom.

Closing 12 months Sky Information exposed proof that at finish of April 2020, the selection of trying out statistics used to be nonetheless so primitive they have been being compiled with pen and paper.

Relating to what used to be recognized concerning the virus extra typically, mins from a SAGE assembly on January 28 display advisers had an image of the primary signs of COVID, however had famous there used to be restricted proof of asymptomatic.

This corroborates Mr Cumming’s advice that knowledge used to be scarce within the first month of the 12 months.

On the other hand, by way of 11 March, the International Well being Organisation had raised the worldwide risk degree to “top” and labeled COVID-19 as a virulent disease – so additional information used to be to be had by way of this level.

:: Dilyn the canine

Mr Cummings additionally alleged that Dilyn the canine averted the PM from focussing on his requires stricter measures to be offered on 12 April.

Dilyn was captured enjoying the recent snow. Pic: Pippa Fowles/No 10
Dominic Cummings stated Boris Johnson’s fiance Carrie Symonds used to be ‘going crackers’ over a tale involving her canine, Dilyn. %: Pippa Fowles/No 10

He instructed MPs the top minister’s fiancĂ© Carrie Symonds used to be “going crackers” over a tale which alleged she used to be making plans to rehome their rescue canine sooner than their child used to be born.

On the other hand, the tale used to be printed at the entrance of The Occasions on Wednesday 11 March, the day sooner than Mr Cummings prompt, with a Downing Boulevard spokesperson having already commented: “It is totally unfaithful that there are plans for him to be rehomed.”

Ms Symonds additionally tweeted on 11 March that the story used to be “general c***”.


Leave a Comment