Dozens of postmasters accused of robbery via Put up Workplace because of misguided IT gadget have convictions overturned


Thirty 9 sub-postmasters who have been wrongly prosecuted via the Put up Workplace have had their legal convictions overturned.

The appellants, a few of whom have been imprisoned for crimes they by no means dedicated, were accused of robbery and false accounting as a result of a misguided pc gadget.

In court docket, Sam Stein QC, the barrister representing a number of sub-postmasters, mentioned the scandal had became the Put up Workplace “into the country’s maximum untrustworthy emblem”.

Protesters outside the Royal Courts of Justice in London
Put up Workplace bosses have apologised to the postmasters and their households for the ‘ancient disasters’

Between 2000 and 2014, the Put up Workplace prosecuted greater than 700 sub-postmasters, on reasonable one per week, after a worm within the pc gadget Horizon resulted in monetary shortfalls in department accounts.

It up to now agreed a just about £58m agreement with 550 sub-postmasters, however maximum of that cash went on prison prices and funders.

Paula Vennells, the manager govt of the Put up Workplace on the time, mentioned in a remark she used to be “deeply saddened” via what had came about.

“I’m really sorry for the struggling brought about to them on account of the convictions which the Courtroom of Enchantment has lately overturned,” she mentioned.

“I totally reinforce and am dedicated to co-operating with the continued Executive Inquiry, as I did with remaining yr’s Make a selection Committee Inquiry.”

The barrister who led that civil declare referred to as Friday’s judgment an “unbelievable victory” that might pave the way in which for extra really extensive repayment.

“That is one thing we will have to all feel embarrassment about – that it ever came about, however cash won’t ever compensate those folks for what is came about to them,” mentioned Patrick Inexperienced QC.

The sub-postmasters appealed their convictions on two grounds: that they’d been denied an excellent trial, and that the instances by which the prosecutions went forward “represents an affront to public sense of right and wrong”.

The court docket granted the attraction of 39 out of 42 postmasters on each grounds, in spite of the Put up Workplace combating 35 of the circumstances on the second one level.

The verdict manner the postmasters may just convey new civil circumstances for malicious prosecution, which might imply the Put up Workplace paying out considerably extra in repayment.

Pronouncing the court docket’s ruling, Lord Justice Holroyde mentioned the Put up Workplace “knew there have been severe problems in regards to the reliability of Horizon” and had a “transparent accountability to analyze” the gadget’s defects.

However the Put up Workplace “persistently asserted that Horizon used to be powerful and dependable”, and “successfully steamrolled over any sub-postmaster who sought to problem its accuracy”, the pass judgement on added.

Lord Justice Holroyde, sitting with Mr Justice Picken and Mrs Justice Farbey, mentioned: “Put up Workplace Restricted’s disasters of investigation and disclosure have been so egregious as to make the prosecution of any of the ‘Horizon circumstances’ an affront to the sense of right and wrong of the court docket.”

Top Minister Boris Johnson tweeted: “I welcome the Courtroom of Enchantment’s determination to overturn the convictions of 39 former sub-postmasters within the Horizon dispute, an appalling injustice which has had a devastating affect on those households for years.

“Courses will have to and shall be learnt to make sure this by no means occurs once more.”

A kind of whose conviction used to be overturned used to be Seema Misra, a former sub-postmistress accused of robbery, who mentioned clearing her title used to be a second she were “dreaming about” for over a decade, however added that it “may not convey again the time”.

Seema Misra, who was jailed for a conviction of theft in 2010, celebrates with her husband Davinder
Seema Misra, who used to be pregnant when wrongly despatched to jail, celebrates along with her husband Davinder

Mrs Misra took over her put up place of work in 2005 and used to be pregnant when she used to be wrongly despatched to jail after being accused of stealing £75,000 from her department.

“I might without a doubt have killed myself if I hadn’t been pregnant,” she mentioned.

Mrs Misra collapsed in court docket when her authentic 15-month sentence used to be learn out.

She informed Sky Information: “Did they even perceive the case? Did they know what are they doing? That point I misplaced religion in justice, I mentioned that is it, that can not be executed, there is not any justice right here.”

The mummy-of-two mentioned she would by no means fail to remember the guilt she felt after leaving jail, including: “It used to be like I had purchased disgrace to the circle of relatives.

“My youngsters are my delight and they did not need folks to peer me and say, ‘Oh, she is Seema Misra’. It used to be all over the place the papers and the whole lot, I did not need to give them a foul title as a result of myself.”

She described the Courtroom of Enchantment verdict as a “massive second”.

When requested if she will be able to now transfer on along with her existence, she informed Sky Information: “I am not positive I will be able to ever pop out of this. I nonetheless need to get up within the morning and say ‘oh it used to be a foul dream’, I will be able to handiest hope.”

Former post office worker Janet Skinner (centre),
Janet Skinner (left) says she is ‘relieved’ to have in any case cleared her title

Janet Skinner, who pleaded responsible to false accounting and used to be sentenced to 9 months in jail in 2007, left the Royal Courts of Justice in London to cheers from supporters.

Ms Skinner mentioned she used to be “relieved” to have in any case cleared her title and that to win her case on each grounds of attraction used to be “wonderful”.

Requested what her message used to be to these answerable for the prosecutions of dozens of sub-postmasters, Ms Skinner mentioned: “Watch your backs.”

Harjinder Butoy, who used to be convicted of robbery and jailed for 3 years and 4 months in 2008, described the Put up Workplace as “a shame” after his title used to be cleared.

Former post office worker Harjinder Butoy (left) hugs his father outside the Royal Courts of Justice
Harjinder Butoy (left) mentioned his ordeal had ‘destroyed my existence for 14 years’

Mr Butoy, who used to be a sub-postmaster in Nottingham, mentioned the tense enjoy had “destroyed my existence for 14 years – that isn’t going to get replaced”.

He mentioned the ones answerable for the scandal “want to be punished, significantly punished”.

He added: “They are simply bullies, that is all they’re… any individual must truly, truly kind this out and price them for this. It cannot be driven beneath the carpet now.”

Tom Hedges, who used to be accused of robbery and false accounting and given a seven-month suspended sentence in 2011, opened a bottle of prosecco after his conviction used to be quashed.

He mentioned: “It is a glorious afternoon. Once I informed my mom, who is 93, I used to be coming to court docket she mentioned ‘get your self all the way down to Aldi and get some prosecco’.

“She mentioned, ‘simply consider your title is Hedges no longer Rothschild, so get prosecco, no longer Bollinger!'”

Former post office worker Tom Hedges
Tom Hedges opened a bottle of prosecco after his conviction used to be quashed

Responding to the judgment, Put up Workplace chairman Tim Parker mentioned: “The Put up Workplace is very sorry for the affect at the lives of those postmasters and their households that used to be brought about via ancient disasters.”

Leader govt Nick Learn mentioned: “The quashing of ancient convictions is an important milestone in totally and correctly addressing the previous as I paintings to place proper those wrongs as all of a sudden as imaginable, and there should be repayment that displays what has came about.”

In a remark, Helen Pitcher, chairman of the Prison Instances Evaluation Fee (CCRC), which referred the 42 sub-postmasters’ convictions to the Courtroom of Enchantment, mentioned: “This has been a major miscarriage of justice which has had a devastating affect on those sufferers and their households.

“Each and every unmarried this type of convictions has obviously had a profound and life-changing affect for the ones concerned.”

She added: “The Put up Workplace has rightly stated the disasters that led to those circumstances and conceded that the prosecutions have been an abuse of procedure.

“We sincerely hope that courses shall be realized from this to forestall the rest identical going down in other places one day.”

3 of the previous sub-postmasters – Wendy Cousins, Stanley Fell and Neelam Hussain – had their appeals disregarded via the court docket.

Lord Justice Holroyde mentioned in those 3 circumstances, “the reliability of Horizon knowledge used to be no longer very important to the prosecution case and that the convictions are secure”.


Leave a Comment